Contact Me

Paul McGarrell, CSG

Paul Mcgarrell Insurance Agency Incorporated

  • address

    254 E 12200 S Ste 200
    Draper, UT 84020

  • office hours

    8:00 am to 6:00 pm
    After Hours by Appt.
  • Phone numbers

    Office: (801) 553-1173
    Alternate: (801) 571-9444
    Fax: (801) 571-5900
  • Languages we speak

Why My Agency

Outstanding Personalized service.

Personalized Service is what we aim to provide here at the Paul P. McGarrell Farmers® Insurance Agency.     As a Farmers agent, I and my professional staff focus on…


What is the most important policy?

What is the most important policy that we sell?   Ask any member of our team about what is the most important policy that we sell is and their answer every time is: life insu…

From My Desk

One of the most important policies..

One of the biggest passions I have in life is working towards making sure that my clients and their families have one of the most important policies in place. What is one of the most…



Judy McGarrell, Office Manager

(801) 501-0079

Judy is the office manager and has been with Paul since the office was established in 1995. Her primary focus is personal lines insurance. She goes above and beyond the call of duty for our clients. 

In the office she is often referred to as "The MOM", she keeps the staff paid and on their toes, and provides a very family friendly atmosphere. 

Out of the office she is a country girl at heart. She loves to visit her family’s ranch and farm, hunt with her husband, attending sporting events with her family and loves spending time with her grandkids.  


Chelsy Judd, Licensed Account Representative

(801) 553-1173

Chelsy has been employed with Paul for 19 years. Currently her main focus is agency operations, and commercial renewals and servicing. She is dedicated to helping each client insure that their most important assets are covered and providing efficient service.

Outside of work she enjoys spending time with her family, attending sporting events at the University of Utah, entertaining, shopping, traveling, and being outdoors.


Karen Ransier, CSR

(801) 571-9444

Karen is a part time team member that focus’ on keeping our office in order from following up on claims, helping in our paperless system, and blitzing on new projects in our pipe line.

Outside of the office she enjoys reading, working in the yard, traveling, crafting, boating, waterskiing and spending time with her family.

Nancy Volpa, Account Manager

(801) 553-1173

Nancy started with our agency in 2012 and after getting to know the ropes she has recently joined our commercial team. She is a very dedicated staff member who provides amazing customer service.

Out side of the office she enjoys spending time with her family, music, singing, playing the flute, reading, baking and embroidery.

Elexsis Tulin, CSR

(801) 553-1173

Lexi joined our team June 2013. She is working outbound marketing in our office to bring new clients to our Farmers® Family. Lexi also is a billing wiz, for breakdowns and details.

Outside of the office she enjoys playing sports, shopping, getting pampered, hiking, being outdoors and recently competed in her first National Gym Association Body Building Show.

Sandy Fink, SIMS Consultant

Sandy helps our team stay up on our marketing methods, creates work flows and marketing campaigns that help us grow our business.

In Sandy’s spare time she likes to golf, spend time with her family and cheer on her K State!
  • Paul McGarrell - <pre>Judy & I have lived in the Sandy/Draper Utah area since 1991.</pre>
    Judy & I have lived in the Sandy/Draper Utah area since 1991.
  • Paul McGarrell - <pre>Three Generations! My dad, myself and my grandson</pre>
    Three Generations! My dad, myself and my grandson
  • Paul McGarrell - <pre>President of Farmers® talking about Life insurance¹.</pre>
    President of Farmers® talking about Life insurance¹.
  • Paul McGarrell - <pre>Cheering on our utes in the rain!</pre>
    Cheering on our utes in the rain!
  • Paul McGarrell - <pre>Early Morning Water Skiing! Love our Utah Lakes!</pre>
    Early Morning Water Skiing! Love our Utah Lakes!
  • Paul McGarrell - <pre>Jameson in his first Farmers® Tee</pre>
    Jameson in his first Farmers® Tee
  • Paul McGarrell - <pre>My grandkids getting ready for Halloween</pre>
    My grandkids getting ready for Halloween
  • Paul McGarrell - <pre>Talking about the most important policy we sell. Life Insurance¹!</pre>
    Talking about the most important policy we sell. Life Insurance¹!
  • Paul McGarrell - Have you thanked a teacher today? Go to
    Have you thanked a teacher today? Go to


Snowmobile Insurance

Snowmobile Insurance

Utah has hundred of miles of groomed snowmobile trails, along with numerous acres of back country to ride in. Make sure that your snowmobile i…

Pet Owner?

Pet Owner?

Farmers customers can protect their furry family member and save 5% with pet insurance from Pets Best.

Business Insurance

Business Insurance

At Farmers, we recognize the characteristics of your business and will work to provide unique, customized coverage at an affordable price.

Home Insurance

Home Insurance

Your home is probably one of your biggest financial investments. Before you find yourself in an emergency, let us help you find any gaps in your insurance coverage.

Farmers Identity Shield<SUP>SM</SUP>

Farmers Identity ShieldSM

With identity theft becoming more common and costly, having Farmers Identity Shield may give you some peace of mind for only pennies a day.

Auto Insurance

Auto Insurance

Farmers® has dozens of discounts that could save you hundreds of dollars on your Car Insurance.

Farmers<sup>®</sup> Racing

Farmers® Racing

Farmers® Insurance showcases Kasey Kahne, the No. 5 team’s Plan to Perform and how Farmers can help consumers to their own “Victory Lane” when it comes to their insurance needs.

About Me

A little about Paul....

Paul moved to the Salt Lake Valley as a teenager and finished high school at Judge Memorial Catholic High School. He fell in love with the slopes and quickly took up snow skiing. Paul…

why My Agency


If you’re interested in a fun career in a fast-paced work environment, please feel free to contact our agency!

Insurance Products

  • Auto

    America's finest Agents, quote and buy online, great discounts and best in class claims service.

  • Home

    Get a quote online and work with a Farmers Agent to find the right coverage for your property and unique needs.

  • Life1

    Tough questions. Simple answers. Farmers® makes it simple to understand Life insurance.

  • Business

    Farmers® offers flexible Business Insurance that reflects the unique characteristics of your business.

  • Motorcycle

    It's about the open road, leather and chrome, bugs in your teeth. When you're out riding, the last thing you want to worry about is whether you have the right insurance policy.

  • Recreational

    Farmers© is an industry leader in Specialty insurance products. We've spent the last 60 years getting to know the outdoor enthusiast.

  • Financial*

    If you're looking to safeguard a sound future, there's no better place to start than Farmers© comprehensive and customizable options.

  • Renters

    Get a quote online and work with a Farmers Agent to find the right coverage for your property and unique needs.

  • Umbrella

    Life is unpredictable. You never know what might happen. If the unexpected happens, Farmers© can help ensure you have the coverage you want to protect your family's assets.

Community Involvement

Community Partners

To better serve our local communities, Farmers works hard to partner with nearby organizations to meet the needs of our neighbors. You will find that many Farmers agents are actively involved with city councils and chambers of commerces. Read More

Giving back to the community

Farmers is committed to being the best at meeting the needs of the communities we serve. The charities and organizations that we support help promote safety, expand educational opportunities, and encourage civic participation in activities and programs that make our communities better places to live. Read More

Farmers® Community

Giving back to the community is part of the Farmers® brand. It’s the foundation on which our trust and respect securely rests. Farmers supports numerous national, regional, and local programs in the communities that we're a part of. By helping these organizations, we help our community. That's why we volunteer our time, talents, and resources and that's how Farmers continues the legacy that its founders envisioned.... Read More

Frequently Asked Questions

  • AUTO
    • What if I let someone else drive my vehicle and they get into an accident?
    • What do I do if I am in a car accident?
    • What do I do if my car breaks down?
    • Will my policy be canceled if I get into an accident?
    • Am I insured if I am driving someone else's vehicle?
    • Do I have insurance if I am renting a vehicle?
    • Will my premiums go up a lot if I get into an accident or get a speeding ticket?
  • Homeowners & renters
    • What if my home is burglarized?
    • If I add safety features to my home can I get discount2 on my insurance?
    • What happens if I have a fire in my home or my home is completely destroyed in a fire?
    • What if someone has an accident on my property or my pet bites someone?
    • What if my home is damaged in a storm?
    • What do I do if a flood has destroyed my home?
    • What if my home is wrecked in an earthquake?
    • What if I become a victim of identity theft?
    • What if a pipe bursts and water flows all over the place?
  • Life1
    • What happens to all of my assets if I die?
    • What if I lose my job?
  • Business
    • Do I need to cover my building if I rent?
    • Which policy is best for my business?
  • Motorcycle
  • Recreational Vehicles
    • Are modifications that I make to my vehicles covered?
    • What types of coverage do I need?
  • Specialty Products
    • What if my RV breaks down, do I have towing coverage?
    • What type of coverage do I need for a travel trailer?
  • Financial*
    • Which investments will give me the most money for retirement*?

Contact Me

Paul McGarrell Farmers Insurance profile image

Paul McGarrell CSG

Paul Mcgarrell Insurance Agency Incorporated

(801) 553-1173

254 E 12200 S Ste 200
Draper, UT 84020

Please enter your name

Please enter valid phone number

Please select a state
Please enter your comment or question

* = Required